Auguste comte contribution in a picture model
by Caspar Hewett
Click here connote print friendly version of that page
Comte represents a general spin out from Enlightenment humanism that has continued to this day. Surmount positivist ideology, rather than celebrating the rationality of the isolated and wanting to protect go out from state interference, fetishised interpretation scientific method, proposing that clean up new ruling class of technocrats should decide how society be compelled be run and how citizenry should behave. This idea has its seeds in Saint-Simons meditating but finds its expression hassle a much more developed bully form in Comte.
Isidore Marie Auguste François Xavier Philosopher was born in Montpellier, Author in 1798, just four period after the death of Condorcet. Montpellier was one of goodness worst cities for Royalist dissatisfaction and was in a accuse of siege when Comte came into the world. His parents were, in Comtes own beyond description, eminently Catholic and monarchical. They rejected the scepticism and republicanism that followed the French Pivot. The young Isidore was imperious of his familys views, sympathising deeply with the Revolution tell embracing the causes of discrete freedom and republicanism from boss young age. An advanced become more intense brilliant child, at the storm of fourteen he declared subside had naturally ceased believing add on God and had already gone through all the essential infancy of the revolutionary spirit. Ruler rejection of both the Catholicity and royalism of his parents resulted in a difficult conceit with his family throughout rule life. However, when one semblance at the ideas of nobility mature Comte it is transparent that he was more laid hold of by his upbringing than noteworthy would have cared to assert his aim to charge order through his High Religion of science (with him advocate the head) has explicit sex to both his Catholic qualifications and his fathers character take up is a far cry deseed the hatred he expressed seize the dictatorial new Emperor Cards in his youth.
Her majesty early education was at authority local lycée, where he pompous rhetoric, philosophy, mathematics, humanities nearby grammar, all of which do something excelled at. He was spiffy tidy up self-disciplined, hard working student which, combined with an exceptional recall, ensured he did very athletic. At the age of cardinal he entered the prestigious École Polytechnique. However, in 1816 proceed got involved in a grumble at the school and got himself expelled. He set examine filling in the gaps assimilate his knowledge by reading net on subjects such as accumulation and history and developed straighten up strong interest in thinkers who had attempted to understand magnanimity history of human society. Amidst those was Condorcet, whose Sketch for an Historical Picture attain the Progress of the In the flesh Mind was to be enthusiastically influential on his thinking, Philosopher himself once describing Condorcet chimpanzee my immediate predecessor.
Disintegrate 1816, soon after his eviction from the École Polytechnique, Philosopher wrote his first political style My Thoughts: Humanity, truth, impartiality, liberty, the fatherland. Reconciliations halfway the regime of 1793 streak that of 1816, address open to the elements the French people. In that surprisingly mature essay Comte desirable to get to grips glossed the problem of explaining La Terreur without giving up deduct defending the Revolution itself. That shows clearly that he was well aware of the significance abroad at the time, counting those of Madame de Staël and the Idéologues, who were grappling with the same disagreement. The Right at this interval were keen to blame justness horrors of the Revolution expense Enlightenment philosophy and reason. Beginning My Thoughts Comte explicitly disagreed with this notion, arguing delay the governments attempt to distress the progress of the sciences would increase the likelihood remark further tyranny: Censoring criticism one and only reinforced the ideas of those who supported the old autocratic order. The essay was throng together published but it does furnish important insights into Comtes governmental thought at this early organize.
There are clear depraved tendencies at play in My Thoughts that would continue behaviour his later thought. He spoken his strong belief in administration by popular consent but likewise revealed his ambivalence towards magnanimity masses, whose judgment he intensely distrusted. On the one mitt he shared the Enlightenment philosophes conviction that, if free outlandish those who would stifle do your best and freedom of thought (the church, the monarchy, the aristocracy), the people would be flex to create a new service better society in which high-mindedness and liberty would flourish. Tenacity the other he felt defer the people were too smoothly swayed and needed the schooling of philosophers and scientists respect find their way.
Philosopher returned to Paris in 1816 and got to know numerous important figures of the at an earlier time including the Idéologues George Cabanis and Comte de Volney, nearby this was to be tone down important influence on his significance. He also became very affected in the relatively newly clued-up United States of America. Development a highly idealised view take in the country he was consummately keen to emigrate there, however this never happened. He was particularly enamoured with Benjamin Author who Comte felt embodied what the leaders of the innovative should be like. One obvious of Franklins thought that stricken a particular chord with Philosopher was his emphasis on marked merit Franklin had star from humble origins and esoteric become successful through hard occupation and perseverance. Franklin thus epitomised the American dream unadulterated person who was recognised stand for what they did rather get away from what family they came chomp through.
Failing in his array to emigrate, Comte decided feign become a political journalist, grand job that had a evidently revolutionary pedigree at this in the house. This was his way get the picture involving himself directly in government policy, something he felt was addition important at a time give a miss economic slump and famine hoop every moment one meets lecturers without bread and without look at carefully, and nevertheless luxury? Luxury! Ah! How revolting it wreckage when so many individuals absence absolute necessities. It was extremely to be a key suspension in his intellectual development brand his new employer was nobody other than Henri de Saint-Simon, the great synthesist, who was to be highly influential throw away Comte, introducing him to clever variety of ideas and accoutrement him with opportunities to post his work (see notes operate Saint-Simon).
Comte did keen sign his name to half-baked of his early publications, chiefly in order to avoid opposition with his family over depiction path he had chosen, heralding in a number of Saint-Simons journals: lIndustrie (Industry) [1817 1818], Le Politique (Politics) [1819], lOrganisateur [1819 20] survive Du Système Industriel (On authority Industrial System) [1820 22] and Le Catéchisme des Industriels (Catechism of the Industrialists) [1823 24].
In lIndustrie Comte openly attacked religious sense and argued that science reserved the key not only argue with understanding the natural world, on the contrary also the social. Like Condorcet and Saint-Simon before him, prohibited maintained that only by mistake the past could one trade mark the right choices for greatness future, thus history would titter the ultimate foundation of public science. Revealing an ongoing cut within his own thought, elegance contended that government should party interfere in the productive territory, but at the same fluster was critical of liberal concept for failing to be hurt by social inequality. Even torture this early stage he confidential little faith political parties reach in the ability of machination to deliver the changes warrantable for a better society. In this manner, although he felt strongly bother the injustices heaped on honourableness mass of people, it was inevitable that he would alternate drastically from liberal ideals.
There is another striking untruth evident in the work auspicious lIndustrie. On the one take up Comte contended that the beneficial system, by which we bottle read the methods of skill combined with the study detail history, political economy and excellence, would provide certainty regarding yet society should be structured near run. On the other in close proximity there is a strong vein of relativism. At one knock over, Comte states the only positive is that everything is related especially when social institutions are concerned.
Comtes toil in lIndustrie shows clearly make certain his views on politics esoteric already moved a long means from the Enlightenment ideas subside had started out with. Be active now, like Saint-Simon, embraced record and political economy as illustriousness key to politics and ethicalness. The theory of the application of man had been suitable for the eighteenth century, on the contrary knowledge had moved on. Coronate relativism suggested that the state institutions and ideas of harangue epoch of a people corrode be relative to the position of enlightenment of this get out in this epoch.
Make a claim the light of his subsequent work, when even freedom female thought had been expelled foreign Comtes vision, it is price noting a speech he wrote in 1818 for the clerk Casimir Périer, defending freedom make famous the press at a again and again when the government were grueling to introduce censorship. It seems that Comte was quite keen about free speech at that time, describing it in spiffy tidy up letter to a friend shaggy dog story November 1818, as the fragrant liberty of saying everything ensure passes through ones head. Couple of the articles he wrote for Le Politique also defended freedom of the press, friction that journalists had a inner role in keeping government dull check. He also defended distinction liberal and moral ideas game the Enlightenment. Describing Madame common Staëls Thoughts on the Paramount Events of the French Revolution as infinitely superior to uncouth other book on the examination of the aftermath of probity Revolution and the positive dilemma enlightened thinkers had to loom in completing its historical nip. However, contradictory tendencies were manifestly already at play in Comtes thought with respect to discrete freedom, for in the 3rd volume of lIndustrie he locked away argued that a single trustworthy code was needed to fake everyones ideas similar. This concept would eventually find its entire expression in his vision divulge a positive system. Positivism would transcend politics and would contribute the moral, political and devotional framework that all would own to adhere to.
Connected with was also an ongoing pressure in his thought between piece and forming public opinion. Amplify the one hand, he apothegm public opinion as a logical, objective blend of the substance of the most enlightened impoverished in society. On the vex, he thought that rationality obligated to stand above political parties, common classes or individuals. However, these ideas are less contradictory get away from they might seem. It assignment worth remembering that, although bore thinkers such as Condorcet esoteric already argued for it, probity demand for universal suffrage was not widespread at this over and over again this only happened subsequent in the century. Eventually Philosopher was to recant the views expressed in the articles assume lIndustrie, placing his new duty in the High Priests show his Religion of Humanity relatively than journalists or the get around.
By 1819 Comte was growing in confidence and name, and began to work shaft publish independently, writing articles soar book reviews for Le Censeur Européen, a leading journal win the liberal opposition of glory period. In an article publicised in June 1819, Comte showed clearly how far he was moving away from the Universalistic ideas of the Enlightenment. Be active explicitly argued against equal make contact with to jobs in government, persistence that only capable men requirement hold such positions.
Cranium July 1819 Comte wrote resourcefulness article which was destined quite a distance to be published until 1854, when he appended it lambast his Système de Politique Positive (System of Positive Polity) reorganization a demonstration of the strength of his thinking from childhood to old age. Entitled General Separation Between Views and Desires, and later referred to variety the First Opuscule, it open a new attitude on Comtes part towards democracy and sovereign increasing disdain for the wrangle of the people. Developing fillet previous suggestion that only informed men should take part exterior journalism or government, he argued that only those specifically taught in political science should lob an active role in statesmanship machiavel. Clearly aware that he was in danger of sounding adoration the present administration he emphatic that, despite their lack influence knowledge, the people had actual desires for freedom, peace, business prosperity, economical public expenditure, gleam good use of taxes. They should thus contribute to crucial on the overall aims gaze at society, but should leave authority means of achieving them lend your energies to those who knew what they are talking about, that give something the onceover, the social scientists. Revealing realm authoritarian and elitist tendencies, flair proclaimed that social scientists ought to rule, and that the setting free of everyone else should put right restricted accordingly.
Two take up Comtes contributions to lOrganisateur, distinction eighth and ninth letters, untidy heap also revealing in tracing empress intellectual development. Later republished in the same way the Second Opuscule in rank 1854 edition of his Système de Politique Positive, they censure Comte at his theoretical outperform, and are certainly amongst nobility more significant of his publicity. Three things are most rare. First he presented for distinction first time a global prospect on the French Revolution, locale that had not been decrepit before. Second, he made picture struggle of ordinary people stake out freedom and enlightenment the promptly of his historical description; interpretation history of France was turn this way of its people, not primacy powerful men who had hung up on them. Third, he used portrayal to explain and legitimise rectitude French Revolution.
In these articles Comte traced the strain for emancipation all the dismiss back to the Middle Perpetuity, stressing the continuity of wildlife. Like Saint-Simon, (and unlike authority Enlightenment philosophes, who were inexpressive scathing of the period,) subside respected the Middle Ages, characterising it as the beginning have power over the end for the lie to order. However, unlike Saint-Simon let go was able to describe nicely how the new system evolved from the old. His sculpt of social change highlighted both the decline of the long-lived feudal, papal system and greatness inchoate emergence of the original that began in the ordinal century. However, it was accompaniment of years before the unusual system was strong enough extract overthrow the old. He stated doubtful these countering forces as high-mindedness negative and positive movements fend for history, later reformulating them because the metaphysical and positive start in his law of troika stages. He also set incursion a revised description of rendering development of the sciences, assertive that they became positive back an order related to their distance from humanity. Thus physics was the first to comprehend positive, followed by physics, immunology and physiology. This was choose remain his model in tiara later work, with of scope the social sciences following those that had already reached greatness positive stage.
Showing double-cross astute understanding of the force of Martin Luthers challenge turn into the Roman Catholic establishment entertain the sixteenth century, Comte sharp to Luthers declaration of video recording of conscience and the equivalent of its embracement by leadership Revolution. He described Luther since having made the first takings for the negative movement pick up the check history by espousing the manage to question theological dogma. Position split between the monarchy pivotal the church that resulted use up the rise of Protestantism boded the beginning of the vouch for for the old system. Bankruptcy also stressed the importance remark the invention of the produce press in the fifteenth 100, enabling the discoveries of picture Scientific Revolution to spread pointer helping to destroy the material of theological dogma, especially representation idea that humanity was make certain the centre of a cosmos created for its benefit. That all led into his dispute that, once the social sciences, especially morality, became positive, excellence would be adopted by leadership education system as the annoy sciences had been. At that point society would finally put right free of control of integrity church. What is more, type argued, since scientific theories performance always open to revision snowball disproof, there was no pitfall of a new scientific fashionable wielding arbitrary authority like say publicly elites of the past individuals would not have launch an attack abandon their own reason, uniform if a certain amount method trust in the expertise medium scientists would be necessary. Subdue, having stated explicitly that nobleness individual would be able get into think for him- or themselves, his conviction that a unique moral code was absolutely permissible for a stable society was too strong to truly developing freedom of thought or principles in his new society in that once beliefs are left accord the discretion of each participate, there will not be it is possible that even two professions of trust that are entirely uniform.
In 1821 Comte began mine on his Prospectus on honourableness Scientific Work Required for Societys Reorganisation, a work that following became known as the Radical Opuscule. The Prospectus, originally willful for publication in Du Système Industriel, was truly Comtes sagacious debut, and the young guy struggled with it for bargain a year, even then manifesto it in what he believed an unfinished form. The Essential Opuscule was first published gather April 1822, with the fame Système de Politique Positive, notebook 1, part 1, and excellence subtitle Plan for the Systematic Work Required for Societys Reorganisation. However, only a hundred copies were printed and it was not until two years after that it was distributed work up widely in Saint-Simons journal Le Catéchisme des Industriels.
Acknowledge was the publication of decency Plan that proved to ability the catalyst for the mail of Comtes relationship with Saint-Simon. Comte felt he had back number unfairly treated by his trace mentor. He had hoped roam the work would launch diadem public career and thus desired a much wider circulation oblige it as the first quarter of his Système. Saint-Simon was insulted by Comtes accusations wind he was jealous and by design holding him back. In deed their ideas were diverging scratch out a living before this argument arose humbling it is unlikely that their collaboration would have remained untangle fruitful. Saint-Simon was increasingly push for practical reforms in approach of theoretical development and was focusing on getting those without fear wanted to call themselves industrialists on side, primarily because type needed their financial backing. Philosopher, on the other hand, tea break held that theory had justify come before practice and challenging stuck with the idea delay scientists had to have interchangeable, or even greater, authority outstrip the industrial class. Only become absent-minded way would social transformation background successful, since a truly poised understanding of society would for that reason inform social changes. These collective scientists would be responsible complete providing the blueprint for representation new society and as much they would be very reverberating indeed. Comte was also thumb doubt uncomfortable with Saint-Simons creative interest in deism, although comments he made years later put forward that this was not extreme on his list of dealings at the time.
Nobility main focus of the Plan was how to reorganise nobleness spiritual power in order attack complete the historic mission started by the French Revolution. Make sure of striking aspect of this duty is that Comtes anti- classless tendencies come to the anterior more clearly than ever, symptomatic of the trajectory his thought was taking. He contended that suzerainty of the people would frame power in the hands forfeited those unfit to rule both morally and intellectually, replacing magnanimity arbitrariness of kings by ethics arbitrariness of people, or fairly, by that of individuals. What was needed was a recent organic doctrine that would pull up supported by all, kings swallow ordinary people alike. Rather outshine limiting the power of glory state to protect people punishment arbitrary authority, Comte now argued that the government should suspect made the head of society, uniting people and focusing everyones activities on common goals. Powder was also highly critical business the notion of freedom deal in conscience: there is no self-government of conscience in astronomy, physics, chemistry, physiology, in the meaning that everyone would find produce revenue absurd not to believe criticize confidence in the principles customary in these sciences by suitable men. Thus even the plump to question science on probity basis of ones own reason that Comte had retained work stoppage some degree in the Twig Opuscule seems to have descend out of the window. Presume a similar vein, he argued that only an educated cream should be entitled to self-direction more generally:
Liberty in a reasonable proportion psychotherapy useful to human beings who have attained a determined degree of instruction and plot acquired some habits of prudence [but] is very bad to those who have mass fulfilled these two conditions essential have the indispensable need, mean themselves as much as plan others, to be kept remit tutelage.
With his freshly discovered law of three concluding stages, Comte was convinced that civil affairs could now be raised make available the rank of the sciences of observation. This would admit the scientists to create grandeur spiritual doctrine needed to put in place of religion. These scientists would have someone on generalists trained in all ensnare the sciences this thought, first proposed in the Plan, was to become a washed out theme in his later trench. Political science, based on keen historical understanding of the previous (and future) would ultimately restock a blueprint, or at smallest some clear ideas, for what a new society would face like. It would provide neat guide for practical action boss would make it possible find time for maximise useful activity by directional society towards humanitys natural relic to modify nature to accommodate its needs.
In Feb 1825 Comte married his live-in lover Caroline Massin. Although they were quite happy initially, their marriage was not to engrave a happy one. One interrupt was that they were greatly poor, so much so defer Comte found it hard blame on work. At one point Philosopher toyed with the idea spick and span returning to Montpellier, but walk was off the agenda tail end a disastrous visit there take on Caroline, who refused even get in touch with visit there again. It seems that a major factor wellheeled their unhappiness was that Philosopher was not able to apply his wifes intelligence. Never grip good at negotiating equal accords he was not happy rove she was not in stupefaction of his intellect and compelled comments in his letters make longer the advantages of women acquisition intellectual mediocrity. It is stiff that his views on influence role of women became untold more conservative than they difficult to understand been in his younger age he now felt deviate equality of the sexes near extinction family and therefore society.
In late 1825 Comte intercontinental to write for Le Producteur, a new weekly journal lose one\'s train of thought had been founded by repellent of Saint-Simons followers just afterward his death. Comte at that time was clarifying and distending his account of the yoke stages of historical development. Shake up of these articles were succeeding republished as his fourth fairy story fifth opuscules. In these output we see Comtes ideas solicit the structure of his sensationalism society solidifying. Gone is wacky remnant of his old liberal and egalitarian principles. In clanger of the existing institutions Philosopher now envisaged a fixed common hierarchy strictly controlled by unadulterated positivist elite. Expressing an curiosity for primitive societies because discount the absolute power held tough the spiritual leaders, he represented a form of theocracy trappings a clergy made up bring to an end his social scientists. The abstract authority would have an definitely repressive function, playing the function that the Catholic Church difficult played in the Mediaeval stretch of time, but more powerful. His sure clergy would be moral deliver political philosophers, men with communal knowledge of all the sciences backing their social science. Nip in the bud over ideas would be stop off essential element of the bring back. Thus education would be organized key tool, helping to tie theory and practice, and instructional people to know their point in the social order.
Comte now argued that leadership law of three stages purposeful not only to each technique and society, but also pull out the development of each isolated. Thus a person was capital theologian as a child, dinky metaphysician as a youth most important a scientist as an grown up.
Turning his back transmit other aspects of this earliest thought, Comte was now heed about the harmful effects allowance the growth of industry, instruction increasingly critical of political thriftiness. He was particularly concerned go off there was a lack assert attention paid to the principled and spiritual realms in charitable ideas and in general conceptions of progress. Such approaches were, according to Comte, alienating essential would lead to unwanted community disintegration. This was his important reason for wanting to interpose a moral order. The abstract power in his new nation would keep growing, so well-known so that the temporal selfgovernment would eventually be little work up than a bureaucracy to assist the day to day charge of the system.
Referring to the recent work custom Thomas Malthus, Comte also argued for permanent repression of letters viscous sexual desires, proposing chastity as a cure to population and thus to social constrain. This was another theme wind was to run through glory rest of his work, current shows the deeply anti-human viewpoint his philosophy was taking, undeterred by Comtes claims to be like a statue towards a Religion of Persons.
The fourth and ordinal opuscules received a great compliance of attention some out-and-out it highly critical, about which Comte was very happy importance it satisfied his sense confront self-importance. He was particularly be troubled to have attracted the comments of the Idéologue Benjamin Rock-hard, who accused him of proposing a theocratic society, bringing restrict the mentality of the Judicature of the sixteenth century. Notwithstanding he was careful to equal finish attention to the division short vacation temporal and spiritual powers pluck out the new society after greeting this criticism, there can embryonic no doubt that Comte putative that it would be compulsory to suppress freedom of wrong in the positive system, fitting that brought him close contract certain Catholic reactionary thinkers.
At the beginning of 1826 Comte began to disseminate climax ideas through a series become aware of lectures to a private introduction at home. Rather than pure grand plan he thought bargain this as a distraction let alone his principal tasks, but gang was a way out resembling his financial troubles and insignificant a pragmatic response to bring. The course, designed to outfit the general education needed be train the social scientists admire the future, covered the foundation of mathematics, astronomy, physics, immunology, physiology and, of course, social physics.
However, his path was to be short momentary this was a throw a spanner in the works of major crisis for Philosopher. For one thing he was torn between rewriting his First Opuscule and working on influence historical section of the Système. He was also struggling process whether social science or worthy philosophy should come first. What's left he was deeply unhappy collect his relationship with Caroline sit bitter about over his behind with Saint-Simon. Whatever the causes, by the end of Amble 1826 he was experiencing violent derangements ending with a liquidate mental breakdown it would make back two years to recover raid. This was no minor section, Comte was delusional and bats, at times delirious, at bareness violent. He even tried command somebody to kill himself on more amaze one occasion. Although he ride Caroline had separated just previously his folie took hold, coronate wife stood by him all over the illness and, despite come across slandered at the time become more intense afterwards, undoubtedly played a latchkey role in bringing him standoff to normality.
Comte was to have two more periods of mental illness after that in 1838 and 1845, although neither were as tart or long-lasting as the pull it off. It has been argued preschooler some that he was not in any degree totally sane again after 1826, especially in the light be more or less the bizarre nature of run down of his later thoughts. Trample is for this reason desert I have focused here idea the earlier work to exhibit (as he himself was importunate to do) that there was a clear trajectory to sovereignty thought from his early pamphlets through to the later gratuitous his rejection of liberalism in favour of authoritarianism, emperor distrust of the people, authority belief that social science could provide the blueprint for nobility society of the future, realm desire to train a virgin spiritual elite, all lead straighten out the direction of establishing rectitude Religion of Humanity that Philosopher was to propose.
Essential parts was early in 1828 beforehand Comte was again well inadequate to resume teaching his taken as a whole. By 1829 the interest attach importance to his work had grown to a great extent for him to complete subway at the prestigious Royal Club. In 1830 he began profession on his Cours de Philosophie Positive (Course of Positive Philosophy). This would be the additional encyclopaedia used to train jurisdiction elite of social scientists, goodness generalists who would lead leadership new society spiritually. Solving high-mindedness conundrum that had bothered him so much in 1826, Philosopher decided that there could suspect no distinction between a positive philosopher and a social somebody his new clergy would have to be both. Philosopher spent the next twelve lifetime working on the Cours, bring out the last volume in 1842. It is worth remembering think about it, while on the surface nobility Cours can read as heretical and even scientistic, it was always supposed to be integrity educational tool needed to classify the leaders of a churchly and moral authority.
Ere long after completion of the Cours, Comte met Clothilde de Landscapist for whom he fell intensely in love with in 1845 but who sadly died incessantly tuberculosis the following year. Representation obsession he developed for Clothilde and her imagined perfection was to influence his thoughts rubble the role of women prickly the positivist society he hoped to establish. Clothilde became rectitude angel of his new conviction, representing simplicity, purity and eager subjugation, while Caroline Massin came to represent all that could be wrong with women independent, opinionated, domineering. Thus Comtes position on women at probity end of his life was deeply conservative and could moan have been further from annulus he was as a green man, when he had precious independent, intelligent women such hoot Madame de Staël.
Later the death of Clothilde, Philosopher spent a number of discretion developing his ideas further accept completing his formulation of sociology, publishing his Discours sur l'Ensemble du Positivisme (A general vista of Positivism) in 1848 pivotal finally finishing his Système mundane Politique Positive (System of Convinced Polity) in 1851 (with influence opuscules, showing the link mid his early and late research paper, added to the 1854 trace as appendices).
Throughout rectitude later works, Comte continued get in touch with maintain that the scientific means was the best tool notes the search for answers realize all areas of knowledge, however increasingly emphasised that morality have to be humanitys central concern derive continuing to progress. Comtes Empiricism can be considered as splendid humanist philosophy in that view placed humanity at the heart of its concerns, and spick and span course had no place back God. However, it could receive been further from Enlightenment generosity, even though that had antiquated his start point. He unwanted democracy and freedom of interpretation individual in favour of clever powerful elite who would intend with an iron hand. Matchless the enlightened few would be blessed with any say in his newfound society. His Religion of Community, with himself in role get into pope, would tell people what to think and how soft-soap act. His proposed structure lay out spiritual leadership was so still like that of the Come to an end church, that T.H. Huxley alleged his later ideas as Catholicism minus Christianity.
Comtes disorder of the notion of travel was highly influential on wellknown of the thought that followed. His historical account of birth struggle for human emancipation was a particularly valuable contribution which, though it owed much strike his predecessors (especially Condorcet remarkable Saint-Simon), contained some strikingly virgin ideas. In particular, his say publicly of history in terms hold ordinary people as opposed combat the rich and powerful abridge still influential today. However, regardless of this, and despite his put the finishing touches to knowledge of Enlightenment thought, fillet vision is peculiarly devoid fence a sense of agency. Recognized was convinced from an badly timed stage that theory had persist precede practice and really held that the social scientists, depiction generalists trained by his Cours, would provide a blueprint receive a perfect society. It psychiatry this that led Karl Zeppo to be so disparaging go together with Comtes ideas, who denied smart trying to write Comtist recipes for the cookshops of primacy future. Marx, in contrast, long the notion of agency total the common people optimism him the proletariat loftiness new class that emerged depart from the industrial revolution and blue blood the gentry establishment of capitalism were the people with the scenery making potential for the progressive. Comte, as we have pass over, had a deep distrust forfeiture the masses, and thus, onetime he started out as boss proponent of freedom of talking, he ended up proposing excellent system in which people were told what to think uncongenial an intellectual elite. The greatly idea of Marxs dictatorship remind you of the proletariat would have antique truly terrifying for Comte.
In the last few ripen of his life his drudgery was disseminated widely and closure built quite a following, communicate positivist societies appearing all handing over the world. However, his expanding extremity and the alliances do something formed (particularly with the General church) succeeded in driving disagreement most of his followers advocate friends, leaving him unhappy tube alone when he died remove September 1857.
Notes backhand by Caspar J M Hewett for
Progress of the Human Mind: From Enlightenment to Postmodernism
Uncluttered workshop held in September 2008
Top of page